The Siege of Mariupol by Christopher A Lawrence
The Siege of Mariupol by Christopher A Lawrence and Stefan Korshak – The Azovstal Steel Plant and Ukraine’s Battle for Survival – is a book I would recommend, but with a big caveat. I will talk mostly about it, but I should say that the book is worth reading and that I am recommending it.
This is a military history book, focused very much on military aspects. What the authors and editor seem to miss is the genocidal nature of russia’s war. This, in addition to assuming that bodies such as amnesty are unbiased, which is a huge mistake to make. The problem with military historians is that they can make assumptions on other aspects, which can be wrong. Of course, historians focused on politics can miss important military aspects as well. This is why I gave the book 4 stars and I recommend it.

There are 2 aspects I will focus on: bombing of the Mariupol Theatre and amnesty international’s report on the bombing of the Mariupol Theatre.
After the bombing of the Mariupol Drama Theatre, on 16 March, a day I will never forget, there were various estimates on how many people died there. An Ukrainian official said 1000 people, later estimates made by Ukrainian officials had the number at 300. AP news said the death toll was of 600. amnesty said that at least 12 people died, after they consulted the russian authorities. The authors, for some reason, believe that amnesty is correct, which is bonkers. They even question if it was “done deliberately”, after mentioning the words in front of the theatre that were 1 m in size.
“There is really no reason to doubt the accuracy or the bias of the amnesty international report.” is something repeated at the end of the book.
This is completely wrong. It was a deliberate attack on a building that housed, possibly, over 1000 people, and hundreds died. I will list why:
– the word “children” in front of it, in russian
– it was shelled to impede rescuers from reaching the building – here is a clip [can be seen by anyone, nothing explicit, it was shared by the BBC] with the shelling that followed
– the upper floor collapsed onto the lower floor
– 12 is not a realistic number at all. For example, when Victoria Amelina [my review of her book] died in a pizzeria in Kramatorsk, 13 people died, out of 80 people in the restaurant. 28 people died in July 2022 in the Vinnytsia missile strike; 18 people were killed in Kharkiv’s megastore. None of these examples had hundreds (if not over a thousand) of people there with the roof and a floor collapsing over them.
amnesty is not a reliable source, pretty much as the other international organisations. I am surprised that a historian takes what they say at face value without questioning it. For example, ICRC was supposed to make a list of all the Ukrainian soldiers who surrendered in May 2022. But they didn’t. The same can be said by all other organisations. Going back to the 12 dead from amnesty.
In August 2022, amnesty released a report in which they accused Ukraine that it “endangers civilians” with army bases in residential areas. This came as a surprise to the amnesty Ukraine’s office, who were not involved in this report. They ignored that, for example, the school used as a base was closed and there were no children in the area. Urban warfare, as the name suggests, involves defending a city. It took a year for amnesty to apologize. A team of 5 experts in international law pointed out that the report ignored that Ukraine was the one defending. If the russians attack civilians, obviously the Ukrainian defenders need to be there to protect the civilians.
Mrs. agnes callamard, the bos of amnesty international, had 5 tweets in total from 24 February 2022 to end of March 2022, in which one was complaining about journalists being nice to Ukrainians [white] when, supposedly, the same journalists were racists towards refugees from other countries. Within a month and a bit from the 7 October and Israeli retaliation, she wrote 40 tweets about Gaza, including at least one with disinformation.
The Siege of Mariupol by Christopher A Lawrence
Details about the picture: –
My rating: 4/5 Stars
Would I recommend it: yes
Published by: Frontline Books
Year it was published: 2026
Format: Hardcover
Genre(s): Military history – Ukraine
Pages: 256
About the author: Christopher A Lawrence is a professional historian and military analyst. He is the Executive Director and President of The Dupuy Institute, an organization dedicated to scholarly research and objective analysis of historical data related to armed conflict and the resolution of armed conflict. The Dupuy Institute provides independent, historically-based analyses of lessons learned from modern military experience. His published works include the 1,662-page Kursk, papers and monographs for the Congressional Office of Technology Assessment and the Vietnam Veterans of American Foundation, as well as over 40 articles written for limited-distribution newsletters and over 60 analytical reports prepared for the Defence Department.
Stefan Korshak is the Kyiv Post Senior Defense Correspondent. He is from Houston Texas, is a Yalie and since the mid-1990s has worked as correspondent/photographer for newswire, newspapers, television and radio. He has reported from five wars but most enjoys doing articles on wildlife and nature.
Website & Social Media Links: –

I have other books about Ukraine that you’ve recommended on my TBR, so I need to read them before adding more.
Kelly recently posted…This or this? #14
This is a good book, but as a military history, is a bit on the dry side. The Ordinary People book or Victoria’s book on women looking at war are much more important to read.