Homelands by Timothy Garton Ash
Homelands by Timothy Garton Ash – A Personal History of Europe – is a book I was eager to read because I know the professor. He is teaching at Oxford and I’ve attended a few events with him. Initially I thought this is a history book, but it is more of a memoir. I can’t consider a history book one where the author uses “I”. He is also sharing his own personal views and snippets from his journals, so it is indeed a personal account of Europe’s history. His father was a soldier on D-Day, he was under surveillance by the Stasi, he advised prime ministers, chancellors, and presidents.
It had potential, but for me it has some rather important issues. So I’ve awarded the book 3 stars and I would recommend it, but with the caveats I’ll mention.

With his amazing knowledge I was surprised by how blind he is to his own biases. The book starts with 2 quotes, one from tolstoy, because tolstoyevski or something. While Ukrainians are dying, something he is well aware of, considering that he has been in Ukraine after the full-scale invasion, praising the so-called “russian culture” is tone-death. Especially tolstoy, whose great-great-grandson is now in the russian duma [parliament] and is sanctioned because of his support for this invasion. It’s like a French quoting Kipling in a book about a current British invasion of India.
He wrote: “what happened in 1990-91 was, in all but name, the final peace settlement left unfinished in 1945”. He is right if we ignore the tanks in Lithuania, Latvia, and Estonia, the armies left in Moldova and Karabakh. moscow was controlling these armies.
He is factually wrong about the people who shot down the MH17 plane. They were not russian-led insurgents, but a russian soldier – Igor Girkin – who has attested to that on camera. He is well known, now in prison because he has spoken against putin. He wants russia’s military do to better, kill more Ukrainians and conquer all of Ukraine.
It was interesting to read that the most tattooed word in Ukraine, according to him, is Volya [freedom]. I am not surprised at all.
Lastly, I will mention a bit at the end of the book. He said that it was not wrong to include russia into G8 and help it modernise. That was wrong. Western Europe, with its tolstoyevski-loving academic elites, completely ignored Eastern Europe and jumped into helping the empire instead of the peoples colonised and oppressed for centuries. How many Czech, Romanian, Moldovan, and Ukrainian authors can he name?
Homelands by Timothy Garton Ash
Details about the picture: –
My rating: 3/5 Stars
Would I recommend it: yes
Published by: Bodley Head
Year it was published: 2023
Format: Hardcover
Genre(s): Memoir
Pages: 363
About the author: Timothy Garton Ash CMG FRSA is a British historian, author and commentator. He is Professor of European Studies at Oxford University. Much of his work has been concerned with the late modern and contemporary history of Central and Eastern Europe.
Website & Social Media Links: –

That’s interesting about the word Volya. Are you a tattoo person? Would you consider getting one of that?
Kelly recently posted…A bouncing update and Mardi Gras
I love tattoos, but I don’t have any. I would consider 3, one of which is a tryzub made out the letters for Volya. Search on google “tryzub volya” to see what I mean.
I looked and saw exactly what I was expecting to see. (you have broadened my knowledge in recent years!) I think that would be a great tattoo! I love tattoos, but only have one because my husband hates them. Both of my daughters and my daughter-in-law have quite a few.
Kelly recently posted…A bouncing update and Mardi Gras
Aww, that’s so nice of you to say.
I am not a fan of needles and this is the main thing that stopped me so far from getting a small tattoo.